(A review article of Sylvia Pankhurst: Sexual Politics and Political Activism by Barbara Winslow (published by UCL Press).)
For anyone espousing communist politics today the appearance of a book which deals seriously with Sylvia Pankhurst’s political progression from militant reformist (suffragette) to revolutionary and left-wing communist is of more than passing interest.
Unfortunately, as the book’s title suggests, the author herself is not really aware that this is what she has elected to do in recording Pankhurst’s years of “political work in the East End of London”. As it happens Pankhurst’s time in the East End (1912-24) spanned some of the most traumatic years of capitalism’s existence, a period which even bourgeois historians have come to recognise as an historical watershed.
War and Revolution: The End of the Old World Order
The years immediately preceding the 1st World War were distinguished by intense class struggle which in Britain presented the capitalist class with the biggest challenge to its rule since Chartism. The World War itself - the barbaric culmination of imperialist competition - brought the biggest human carnage the world had ever seen. As well as shaking the very foundations of the existing political and social order, the war undermined bourgeois self-confidence in its ‘civilising mission’ and automatic right to rule. For the working class throughout Europe the reformist scenario of socialism evolving naturally and peaceably out of capitalism was shattered. With the notable exception of Russia and Serbia, Socialist Parties in all the warring countries abandoned any pretence that they would oppose workers killing each other for the sake of the national interests of their own capitalist class. As with the Social Democratic Party (SPD) in Germany, the Labour Party promised to support the war effort. Apart from a few token demonstrations called by the pacifists in the ILP as war was declared, Labour gave full support to the War. In 1915 Ramsay MacDonald, a pacifist, resigned the leadership (though not his seat in parliament), not in order to protest at his party’s endorsement of war, but so that he could have an easy conscience about Labour MPs joining the wartime coalition governments. There was no objection from those MPs to the passing of the Munitions Act which outlawed strikes on war work (accepted by the TUC) or the various additions to the Defence of the Realm Act (DORA) which gave the state almost unlimited power against anything it interpreted as a possible threat to the “war effort”. Yet, as the dead piled up in their millions on the battle fronts and life for a working class subject to military discipline and material hardship on “the home front” became intolerable, the necessity for a truly civilised way of organising the human community became increasingly obvious.
The Russian Revolution of February 1917, which overthrew the Tsarist autocracy, offered the possibility of a way forward to the rest of Europe’s war-weary working class. It demonstrated that there was a practical alternative to bourgeois rule, to capitalism’s organised mass butchery of worker by worker and governments whose basic aim was to protect the bosses who were flagrantly profiting from the war. That alternative was soviet power - direct government by workers themselves through a system of nation-wide councils composed of directly elected and recallable delegates. At first the soviets deferred to the provisional government hastily set up by ex-Tsarist ministers who thought that nothing much would change inside Russia except that there would be a parliament as in the other Allied states. The Bolshevik, October Revolution of the working class which overthrew the bourgeois provisional government and which finally took Russia’s “workers and peasants in uniform” (Lenin) out of the war confirmed the revolutionary potential of the soviets. That potential, however, could only be fully realised once the soviets in Russia became part of a network of, first a European-wide socialist republic and eventually a world-wide socialist community. But if the survival of soviet power in Russia depended on its extension throughout Europe the prospect of such a revolution occurring was that much greater once European workers had the example and inspiration of the Russian Revolution before them. Indeed the mutinous situation in the German fleet had already been taken into account by the Bolshevik leadership when timing the October insurrection. After October mass strikes spread through the major cities of the old Austro-Hungarian empire, Vienna and Budapest, to Berlin and other German cities. When the 2nd All-Russian Congress of Soviets issued a peace decree calling for a “just, democratic peace without annexations and indemnities” and followed by the publication of the Tsar’s secret deals with the Allies on how they intended to share the imperialist spoils European workers’ disillusion in the war aims of their respective governments increased. But the European soviet revolution still did not occur. Instead of “issuing a few revolutionary proclamations to the peoples of the world” and then shutting up shop as he had supposed, Trotsky, as People’s Commissar for Foreign Affairs, was obliged to sue for separate peace terms with Germany at Brest-Litovsk. In Berlin metal workers responded by striking against the terms of the Treaty and in Kiel sailors formed their own council (or soviet) and appealed to the international working class to join them in putting an end to the war. By November 1918, when Germany’s military leaders finally signed the armistice (1) they did so because they had no choice - the revolution had arrived. Workers’ councils had appeared throughout the land and the Kaiser had already abdicated. But it was a revolution without a communist party that could give a clear political lead to the working class on how to establish and maintain soviet power. As yet the largest group of communists, the Spartacists, were still inside the left social democratic party (USPD). Just as Social Democracy had supported the war, it was the Social Democrats of right and left who undermined the workers’ revolution in Germany right from the start. So, while tens of thousands of workers in Moscow celebrated the beginning of the world revolution and the end of their own isolation the Social Democrats in the council of workers and soldiers delegates in Berlin adopted a revolutionary vocabulary, confirmed that Germany was now a “socialist republic” and proposed the appointment of an Executive Committee of “people’s commissars” (six Social Democrats) which was duly ratified. On the same day Ebert, one of the most reactionary SPD leaders and now chairman of the “people’s commissars”, made a deal with Groener, Chief of the Army, for a mutual fight against Bolshevism.
The story of how Social Democracy saved German capitalism by a combination of armed force and political weakening of the revolutionary movement from within cannot be retold here. But as the revolutionary wave reverberated throughout Europe so too was this echoed by the leftward shift of social democratic parties anxious to divert the class movement onto safe “constitutional” capitalist ground. In Italy the Socialist Party was one of the first to declare its formal allegiance to the newly-formed Communist International (1919) while in practice it did its best to undermine just about everything it stood for in a sea of confusion and deliberate procrastination. Serrati, for instance, refused to expel the right-wing parliamentarists who openly opposed the idea of workers destroying the capitalist state apparatus and establishing their own rule on the completely different basis of direct soviet democracy. Indeed, the columns of the Party paper blurred the issue even further by endless debate over what the role of soviets or councils really was. During the Biennio Rosso or Red Two Years (1919-20) of, at times insurrectionary, class struggle in Italy the PSI leadership refused to condone it. When mass strikes broke out in Piedmont and Turin, culminating in the famous factory occupations, the Party leadership did its best to deprive the movement of any revolutionary significance by declaring that this was not a political but an economic issue which was the province of the trade unions!
Labour Aids the British Ruling Class
In Britain the ripples of the revolutionary wave were weaker but they were there all right - and so was Labour, ready to stem the tide. News of the February Revolution in Russia reached the British working class at a time of growing disillusion with the war and the working conditions imposed by what was in effect industrial conscription. Since the TUC was working hand in glove with the government to prevent strikes it was up to rank and file workers to organise on their own account. 1917 saw the revival of the workers’ committee movement which had first appeared in 1915 amongst the shipyard and engineering workers on the Clyde. This time the hub of what came to be known as the shop stewards’ movement was in Sheffield - where nearly 45,000 workers were employed in arms factories - but it was a movement which extended throughout Britain’s main engineering centres. The government began to get the measure of its strength in May 1917 when it announced the abolition of the Trade Card scheme exempting skilled workers from military service. For three weeks there were strikes all over the country, involving 200,000 workers. In itself it was a sectional issue and the Trade Card scheme was duly abolished. Even so, anti-war feeling was growing amongst the working class, encouraged by news from Russia where the Provisional Government was under pressure from the workers’ soviets to demand an immediate peace without annexations or indemnities. This was the signal for Labour to make a shift to the left in order, not only to try and maintain working class commitment to British imperialism’s war aims, but to reduce the possibility of a more political movement developing that would threaten the British state. Thus, the Leeds Convention of over 1,000 anti-war ‘socialists’ held in July was dominated by Labour Party bigwigs and trade union leaders moving resolutions to express British working class support for the Russian Revolution (Ramsay MacDonald MP), for the Russian Provisional Government’s war aims (Philip Snowden MP) and for the establishment:
"in every town, urban, and rural district, Councils of Workmen and Soldiers’ Delegates for initiating and co-ordinating working class activity in support of the policy set out in the foregoing resolution, and to work strenuously for a peace made by the peoples of the various countries, and for the complete political and economic emancipation of international labour." (W.C. Anderson MP)
Behind these high-sounding phrases there was nothing remotely revolutionary. Since the Russian Provisional Government’s aim was to continue the war on the Eastern front what the working class in Britain were really being called on to do was keep up their support for the war on the Western front. The call for the formation of workers and soldiers councils was more to head off the possibility of a more serious initiative than anything else. Certainly the mover of the resolution had nothing “subversive, not unconstitutional” in mind and nothing practical came of it, which is unsurprising since Anderson also asked the assembled delegates “not to discuss too much the mere method by which it will be done”.
Rather than busy themselves with setting up workers’ councils Labour leaders were regrouping round the Party’s newly-drafted War Aims Memorandum (MacDonald) - essentially taken over from the Union of Democratic Control and designed to cut the feet from under the growing anti-war movement by redefining the Allied war aims in suitably democratic terms - and drafting the party’s first-ever constitution (Sidney Webb and Arthur Henderson). This latter, as Pankhurst put it in The Workers’ Dreadnought,
"... is so vaguely drawn that Mr Sidney Webb, a member of its Executive, is able to describe it as embodying: “A Socialism which is no more specific than a definite repudiation of the individualism that characterises all the political parties of the past generation.” (2)" (17-11-1917)
No matter. In the winter of 1917-18, with growing war weariness and strikes of skilled and unskilled workers spreading, news of the second Bolshevik Revolution reached Britain’s workers. The Labour Party was now ready to pose as being both in favour of a ‘democratic’ peace and as socialist. On January 5-6th 1918 a joint conference of shop stewards and Amalgamation Committees (syndicalist propaganda bodies) enthusiastically declared solidarity with the November Russian Revolution and in addition to discussing fighting the government’s new Man Power Bill, decided that delegates go back to their workplaces and sound out the possibility of strike action to stop the war. As James Hinton summarises,
"During the last weeks of January 1918 it was touch and go whether or not the munitions workers would erupt into a political strike, demanding immediate peace negotiations on the Bolshevik terms of no annexations, no indemnities."
The Labour leaders sensed this no less than the Prime Minister, Lloyd George. At the same time as the shop stewards were discussing strike action to stop the war Lloyd George spoke to a conference of trade union leaders and endorsed Labour’s newly articulated war aims.(3) This prepared the ground for the Labour Party Conference a fortnight later to make no bones about backing the Government and for a wholehearted appeal for "restraint" on the part of the working class - notably led by that recent advocate of soviets, Sheffield left-wing MP W.C. Anderson, who argued that:
"A terrific industrial upheaval at the present moment might be dangerous from the standpoint of a democratic People’s Peace... (4)"
The combination of Left and Right capitalist propaganda seems to have done the trick. Just as today, imperialist war was now being waged under the banner of the pursuit of peace. When the National Council of shop stewards met in the last week of January the call for a co-ordinated national strike against the war did not come. Although the Clyde Workers Committee and London shop stewards were in favour [and organised protest meetings in the Albert Hall and Glasgow], significantly it was the report that Sheffield workers were opposed to a political strike that was the decider. Ironically and tragically, this was while Trotsky was stalling at Brest-Litovsk and 400,000 Berlin munitions workers were being forced back to work after striking for peace along...
"the principles formulated by the Russian People’s Commissioners in Brest-Litovsk. (5)"
Towards a Communist Party in Britain
Even before the creation of the 3rd International, this failure of the working class movement as a whole to move on to political and potentially revolutionary ground in 1918 was the impetus for Britain’s divided revolutionary minorities to begin to move towards regroupment. The first step came from the BSP (British Socialist Party), itself by no means a clear revolutionary organisation, when its annual Easter conference in 1918 decided “That the time has arrived for the co-operation of all active Socialist forces” and started to make overtures towards the much more consistently revolutionary SLP (Socialist Labour Party) and the ILP (Independent Labour Party), Labour’s non-trade unionist left-wing which at the most generous could only be described as “Centrist” ("Socialist in word and chauvinist in deed”, Lenin). After the war the process received further encouragement from the formation of the Communist International - which called on European revolutionaries to break from Social Democracy and form communist parties - and from the resurgence of the class struggle. (In simple terms of strike days, there were more strikes in 1919 than for the whole of the four exceptionally militant years before the war put together.) By now Sylvia Pankhurst, on behalf of the Workers’ Socialist Federation (WSF) was playing a leading part in what arguably should have been a deeper process of clarification over what is socialism and how it can come into being but which became a protracted and labyrinthine set of negotiations around how far the new party could use parliament and the unions and, above all, the issue of affiliation to the Labour Party.
By the time unity was achieved (with the Leeds Unity Convention of January 1921) it was minus the contribution of one of Britain’s best known revolutionary Marxists, John Maclean, and without a large part of the SLP. Within six months the CPGB (Communist Party of Great Britain) had expelled Pankhurst. By now the revolutionary tide had ebbed. In Russia a working class decimated by civil war and famine was left without support and with the soviets virtually emptied of genuine political life. As counter-revolution stared the Bolsheviks in the face they became more and more desperate to break Russia’s isolation, even as the Party itself became the vehicle of the counter-revolution by virtue of its control over the state. With the introduction of the NEP (New Economic Policy) in 1921 Lenin acknowledged that this was state capitalism. At the same time the first moves to ban critical voices from inside the Party were made with the 10th Congress resolving on the immediate dissolution of all groups with platforms - a resolution aimed specifically at the Workers’ Opposition which was demanding freedom for the trades unions. Bolshevik desperation was reflected in the growing opportunism of their tactics adopted by the International. At the 3rd Congress Communist Parties in Europe were urged to “go to the masses” and transform themselves into mass parties in part by winning over the leaderships of the trades unions. This was followed by the call to build the “united proletarian front”. Any ambiguity as to what Moscow might mean by this was removed by the time of the 4th Congress which ratified the “workers’ government” slogan and encouraged agreements with Social Democracy, the very current whose parties had been recognised “beyond doubt, as the class enemies of the proletariat” at the founding Congress.
Pankhurst Moves Away from Reformism...
This changing historical context needs to be spelled out because without it Pankhurst’s political journey remains incomprehensible, even to the most sympathetic biographer. For readers who don’t know Pankhurst’s story, she began political life alongside her famous mother and sister in the Women’s Social and Political Union (WSPU) an organisation which they had helped to found in Manchester in 1903. The WSPU aimed to win votes for women on the same terms as men. Although this would exclude the majority of working class women, the WSPU, like the Pankhursts themselves, was linked to Labour via the ILP [Independent Labour Party]. After moving to London in order to take a more influential part in the women’s suffrage movement, the older women left the ILP which was ambivalent about votes for women [1906] and concentrated more and more of their efforts on winning over rich bourgeois and aristocratic women to “the cause”. The WSPU as a whole, however, maintained the ILP connection while Sylvia herself remained committed to a characteristic ILP idealist socialism as well as to the increasingly militant female suffrage movement. She chose to work more with the WSPU in the East End of London and developed close links with local ILPers, including George Lansbury who lost his parliamentary seat in 1912 after running on a female suffrage ticket without the support of the ILP/Labour as a whole - which officially supported adult suffrage, although doing little about it. This was the signal for the elder Pankhursts to break completely with the ILP/Labour, to stipulate that no WSPU member appear on a platform with men, and to abandon work in the East End. It also signalled a rupture with Sylvia who resolved to continue working inside the working class and set up her own East London Federation of Suffragettes (ELFS). In the run-up to the 1st World War Pankhurst immersed herself in the class struggle as she fought for female political equality, a fight which she brought to working class women and which she made part of the struggle for socialism. In so doing she provoked further wrath from her feminist mother and sister who eventually expelled the ELFS from the WSPU after Sylvia spoke at a workers’ rally in the Albert Hall. This had been organised to support striking workers and the release of Jim Larkin, in prison on hunger strike, during the 1913 Dublin lock-out. Amongst others on the platform with Sylvia Pankhurst was James Connolly, founder member of the SLP who would later be summarily executed by the British army in the aftermath of the 1916 Easter Rising. It was after this political breach, in March, 1914, that Pankhurst published the first edition of the ELFS weekly newspaper, The Woman’s Dreadnought,
"to deal with the franchise question from the working woman’s point of view. (6)"
The rupture with Emmeline and Christabel became final with the outbreak of the 1st World War in 1914 when, as Winslow puts it, the WSPU “almost overnight” became “vociferously patriotic” and the suffragette movement collapsed. The ELFS too suffered a haemorrhage of members but a core remained with Sylvia Pankhurst who took up a pacifist anti-war stance. Pankhurst was no marxist and she did not have the clarity of a John Maclean or the SLP about the imperialist nature of the war and its significance for the working class but she held to the spirit of the 1907 and 1912 anti-war resolutions of the 2nd International. In December 1914 the Dreadnought printed an article by Karl Liebknecht arguing that the war was caused by an imperialist struggle over the world market and Winslow maintains that Pankhurst was behind all the anti-war demonstrations in London during the first two years of the war. (The biggest was in April 1916 when a WSF phalanx marched the six miles from Bow to Poplar and on to Trafalgar Square as part of a demonstration of 20,000.) By this time “WSF” stood for “Workers Suffrage Federation” and was expanding its forces beyond the East End of London. Pankhurst herself was becoming more involved with the class struggle throughout the country and developed closer relations with other revolutionaries, notably John Maclean and the SLP. However, her world view was still essentially social democratic - with the attainment of full democratic rights within capitalism seen as the key to both ending the war and the establishment of socialism itself. Over the next two years that world view was to dramatically change under the impact of the Russian Revolution and the revolutionary wave that followed in its wake.
The response of the WSF to the February Revolution in Russia was to change the name of its paper to The Workers’ Dreadnought (28th July 1917). The same edition ran an article giving news of Russian workers’ and soldiers’ councils and calling for similar organisations to be formed in Britain. However, the social democratic outlook did not disappear overnight. It wasn’t until May 1918 that the Workers’ Suffrage Federation became the Workers’ Socialist Federation and not until July that “Votes For All” finally disappeared from the _Dreadnought_’s banner. (Replaced by “For International Socialism”). Ironically, given her own confusion, Pankhurst’s idiosyncratic welcome for what she termed “the Lenin revolution” suggests that she herself had just begun to realise the value of having a clear socialist programme.
"...the Russian Socialists are now heading straight for Socialism, and for years past have been busily hammering out the programme and learning confidence in themselves and in it. The educational value of a programme ... is very great ...Without the knowledge that such study will bring them, revolution would only mean a change of master... The Russian problem is our problem: it is simply whether the people understand Socialism and whether they desire it."
As it was, Pankhurst’s own understanding of socialism was being revolutionised by the reality of the class struggle and from the wider political horizons that contact with international revolutionaries brought. By the time almost universal suffrage was granted in Britain she was questioning its value: “Is it possible to establish Socialism with the parliament at Westminster as its foundation?”, she asked in the Dreadnought in February 1918. At the general election at the end of the war - when the working class were “rewarded” for their loyalty to British imperialism with the right to vote - she commented:
"We hope nothing from this election, save that it may serve to spur the workers on to abolish Parliament, the product and instrument of the capitalist system, and to establish in its place Councils of Workers’ Delegates, which shall be the executive instruments for creating and maintaining the Socialist community." (Workers’ Dreadnought, 14th December 1918)
.... Becomes a Revolutionary Internationalist
Like other revolutionaries in Britain, notably the SLP with its leanings towards industrial unionism and links with the shop stewards’ movement, Pankhurst began to see workers’ committees as potential soviets. In early 1918, the WSF established close relations with the London shop stewards of the ASE (Amalgamated Society of Engineers). At that point not only was a strike against the war on the agenda but rocketing food prices and the dire shortages which brought endless queuing caused the shop stewards to seriously consider taking over supplies and distributing food via the workers’ committees. The stewards formed a National Food Vigilance Committee with the avowed aim of obtaining “the effective control of the production and distribution of all foodstuffs”. (7)
Winslow notes in passing that Pankhurst was a member of this committee when it met on January 12th in Battersea Town Hall and "pledged to strike" towards this end [p.111]. The government recognised the threat to its authority and quickly introduced rationing to avoid the threat becoming a real challenge. (8)
However, this was not the end of the workers’ committees or the WSF’s continued association with the movement, reflected by regular reports in the Dreadnought. When the WSF changed its name and adopted a new constitution in May 1918 it committed itself to the abolition of capitalism and the parliamentary system which would be replaced by workers organising on an industrial basis and building up a National Assembly from local workers’ committees.
At the same time Pankhurst was developing links with the revolutionary movement outside of Britain and using the Dreadnought to publicise news and political articles on issues of international significance for the working class. Reports on the German Revolution, news of Liebknecht and Luxemburg’s deaths, soviets in Bavaria, the Winnipeg Soviet, the Italian Socialist Party and the class struggle in Italy, were interspersed with articles by John Reed on the structure of the soviet state, Bukharin on soviets or parliament, Lenin and Chicherin addressing British workers, Pannekoek on the Dutch Communist Party ... and much else. She also quickly realised that workers needed to know more about revolutionary Russia apart from hostile reports in the bourgeois press and from Labour Party apologists like Sidney Webb and in July 1918 set up the People’s Russian Information Bureau (PRIB), a precursor of the “Hands Off Russia” movement which urged workers to oppose Allied military intervention against the Revolution. Pankhurst could also boast that the Dreadnought was the first in Britain to welcome the formation of the 3rd International and in 1919 she wrote four articles for its official journal, Communist International. The last of these, Winslow states, was printed anonymously. It was Pankhurst’s letter to Lenin on the impossibility of revolutionaries participating in elections and parliament. As Lenin argued in his reply, the issue in itself was a secondary one which did not justify delaying...
"the formation of a big workers’ Communist Party in Britain out of all the trends and elements, listed by you, which sympathise with Bolshevism and sincerely support the Soviet Republic. (9)"
At heart, though, the debate in Britain was not simply about the ability of a really revolutionary party to send “revolutionary propagandists, such as Karl Liebknecht” to parliament but about commitment to the revolutionary dictatorship of the proletariat and abolition of parliament in favour of a soviet (or council) system. It was precisely this commitment that the BSP (British Socialist Party) leadership had not been able to give the WSF when they had discussed merging their two publications in May 1918. It was not until October 1919, after a full balloting of its membership, that the BSP, which was affiliated to the Labour Party, decisively came out in favour of joining the 3rd International. Before then it was revolutionaries like John Maclean, the SLP and then Pankhurst herself who were seen as the kernel of a future revolutionary party in Britain by Lenin and the Bolshevik leadership. In fact the WSF had already pronounced itself for the 3rd International and adopted the title of Communist Party only to delay the use of the name pending the outcome of the unity negotiations...
"in order that the new united party, which is hoped will eventuate, may adopt the title Communist Party as its own." (Workers’ Dreadnought, 21-06-1919)
In the meantime Pankhurst embarked on a political trip through Europe. By October she was in Bologna addressing the Italian Socialist Party and speaking on behalf of Bordiga’s abstentionist fraction against Serrati:
"It is difficult for me to understand how you can possibly make propaganda to win seats in parliament - a body which you mean to abolish in a few months - when you ought to be absorbed in the work of revolutionary preparation and when the most urgent need is to convince workers that the time for Parliament has passed." (Quoted p.142, from a translation of the report in Il Comunismo)
From Italy Pankhurst went on to a meeting of the West European Secretariat of the International in Frankfurt. February 1920 saw her alongside J.T. Murphy of the SLP and two BSPers at the founding conference of the short-lived “ultra-left” Amsterdam Bureau of the International. Here Pankhurst met fellow anti-parliamentarists, Herman Gorter and Anton Pannekoek. Presumably [because Winslow does not clarify] she also helped to draw up the resolution to British communists on non-affiliation to the Labour Party, a resolution accompanied by an “appeal to our English friends to unite on the basis of no affiliation with the Labour Party” (10), which conflicted with Lenin’s view and hastened the dissolution of the Bureau.
... Opposes Affiliation with Labour
Back in Britain the question of communist regroupment became reduced to one of affiliation or otherwise with the Labour Party. The decision of the Amsterdam Bureau was outweighed by the fact that Lenin was in favour of affiliation and that the Russian Party’s financial and organisational weight was behind unity on the widest possible basis - i.e. with the BSP, the largest of the groups which had come out in support of the Communist International but the one which retained the heaviest social democratic baggage. The fact that the BSP was affiliated to the Labour Party no doubt encouraged Lenin in his illusion that it was possible for a Communist Party to work within Labour without losing political independence. Even so, Lenin’s desperation in 1920 that communists in the West maintain links with the masses led to opportunism, as his arguments in Left-Wing Communism show. Dividing up constituencies, supporting Labour so that it can have a trial run in office and thereby “prove” to the masses that it is anti-working class (the “support of a rope for the hanged man” argument still used by the capitalist left today), were not the same as using parliament as a revolutionary platform, they were a step back from the very raison d’etre for the formation of the 3rd International, i.e. That:
"An essential condition of victory ... is that the proletariat make a break not only with the outright lackeys of capital and the hangmen of the Communist revolution, such as the right-wing social democrats, but also with the ‘centre’ (the Kautskyites), which abandon
